Last updated October 5, 2026 · ranked from 4,231 Google reviews · How we rank
This list ranks 9 pizza places in and around Oak Park, MI, led by Mother Handsome, Pie Sci Pizza | Oak Park and Pizza Square. Together they have 4,231 Google reviews; Mother Handsome has the highest Google rating on the list at 4.7. Every place on the list is in Oak Park, MI. Rankings weigh Google rating, review volume, how complete and current each listing is, and our own notes on each place.
A cafe by day and bar-pizzeria by night, Mother Handsome earns the top spot with a 4.7-star Google rating across 354 reviews and flexible ways to visit. At 14661 W Eleven Mile Rd, Suite 500, in Oak Park, MI, it offers indoor and outdoor seating, plus takeout, delivery and curbside pickup. Beer, wine and cocktails accompany the evening pizzeria setup, while Friday and Saturday hours extend to midnight. Reviewers praise the welcoming atmosphere and kind service.
Bar and pizzeria
Indoor and outdoor seating
Weekend midnight closing
“This is a hidden gem! Such a cute spot. The Mocha and blueberry lemon loaf was so tasty. The service was great, and the atmosphere was so chill. It was a welcoming spot. Not overall loud or crowded. Looking forward to my next visit.”
Inventive weekly specials and unusual flavor combinations give Pie Sci Pizza | Oak Park its No. 2 spot. This Detroit-style pizza place at 8150 W Nine Mile Rd in Oak Park, MI offers vegan, vegetarian, and gluten-free options alongside its broader menu. Reviewers praise the pies and consistent quality; one repeat customer singled out the Little Sticky with added pepperoni. A 4.5-star Google rating from 264 reviews supports that feedback. Counter service, takeout, and delivery provide several ways to order lunch or dinner.
Detroit-style pizza
Inventive weekly specials
Vegan options available
“We’ve ordered from here many times before and always enjoyed our food. However, yesterday we had the Little Sticky added pepperoni and it was out of this world crazy delicious! I am obsessed. You need to keep this on the menu!”
More than 33 years in operation, according to its business description, gives Pizza Square a long history on W Nine Mile Rd in Oak Park, MI. Its No. 3 spot is supported by a 4.4 Google rating from 217 reviews, with reviewers praising fresh, consistently cooked pizza and friendly owners. Carryout and delivery are central to this mom-and-pop pizzeria, though dine-in seating is also available. Vegetarian and vegan options, free parking, and Friday hours until 10 p.m. add practical reasons to visit.
Carryout and delivery
Vegetarian and vegan options
Free parking
“I found out this Pizzeria about a week and a half ago and boy was I glad. The service was excellent and the owners were very friendly and polite. The food took a normal and expected time of any pizza shop to be ready.
The best part was h…”
Late hours and positive pizza reviews help earn Papa’s Pizza & BBQ its No. 4 spot in Oak Park, MI. The casual chain location at 15400 W Nine Mile Rd serves classic pies alongside comfort food such as ribs, with takeout and delivery available. Reviewers praise the pizza, service, and hot food, and its Google rating stands at 4.2 from 639 reviews. It stays open until midnight Sunday through Thursday and until 1 a.m. Friday and Saturday, making it useful for a late meal.
Classic pizza pies
Late weekend hours
Takeout and delivery
“always the best service & quality. Super clean. the best pizza”
Flavored crusts give Hungry Howie's Pizza its clearest distinction at No. 5, with sesame and garlic herb among the options listed. This counter-serve location at 24691 Coolidge Hwy in Oak Park, MI pairs a lower-cost price category with takeout, delivery and no-contact delivery. Friday and Saturday hours extend to midnight, making it an option for a late pizza order. Free lot and street parking add convenience for pickup, while one reviewer praises the well-priced deals, Howie bread and wings.
Flavored crust options
Midnight weekend closing
Free pickup parking
“My experience was not good., my order was messed up and when I went back the next day to get a rectified the staff took it upon themselves to remake the order they really skimped on all of the ingredients even the sub the ham and cheese …”
Late hours and several ways to order give Little Caesars Pizza its practical appeal at No. 6. At 8801 W Nine Mile Rd in Oak Park, MI, this low-price carry-out chain serves pizza tossed from housemade dough, alongside chicken wings and signature breadsticks. Takeout, drive-through and delivery are available, with closing times of 11 p.m. most nights and midnight Friday and Saturday. Its 3.5-star Google rating across 833 reviews comes with a caveat: the supplied reviews report lengthy pickup waits and service problems.
Housemade pizza dough
Late-night hours
Drive-through available
“Your gonna wait 1hr in the drive thru. And the service is horrible. No sign that says they don’t take $50. All around bad experience”
Late-night hours and low-tier pricing give Happy's Pizza practical appeal at No. 7. Located at 13700 W Nine Mile Rd in Oak Park, MI, it serves pizza alongside barbecue and other comfort food, with counter seating, takeout and delivery available. It stays open until midnight Sunday through Thursday and 1 a.m. Friday and Saturday. The supplied reviews praise fast service, accurate orders and hot, fresh food, while its overall Google rating stands at 3.4 from 364 reviews.
Budget pricing and daily 11 a.m.–10 p.m. hours earn Little Caesars Pizza its No. 8 spot as a practical takeout option in Oak Park, MI. The Coolidge Highway location offers pizza tossed from housemade dough, plus chicken wings and signature breadsticks. Delivery and free lot and street parking add convenience. Its 3.2-star Google rating from 416 reviews and excerpts reporting long waits and service problems keep expectations grounded: the case here rests on affordability and ordering options, not speed or a sit-down experience.
Budget pricing
Housemade pizza dough
Takeout and delivery
“My fiance and I went to this location yesterday (09/30/26) a little after 8:30pm. She went to place our order and the worker stated they only take online orders after 8pm. My fiance asked was this for all locations and she replied back y…”
Late hours and low listed pricing give Domino’s Pizza at 13735 W Nine Mile Rd a practical role at No. 9 in Oak Park, MI. This carryout-and-delivery location stays open until midnight Sunday through Thursday and 1 a.m. Friday and Saturday, with free lot and street parking for pickups. One reviewer praised pizza that arrived hot. Its 2.6-star Google rating across 613 reviews and complaints about service and canceled preorders temper those strengths, keeping it at the bottom of this list.
Late weekend hours
No-contact delivery
Free pickup parking
“the black guy in the store right now but a hair the pizza bec my order was $82 dollars”
Ratings and review counts shown are Google ratings, displayed with attribution.
How we ranked this list
Each pizza place is scored on a Bayesian-weighted rating (its rating adjusted for how many reviews it has compared with the Oak Park category average), how recently we verified its details, and how complete its listing is. Scores and ranks are stored, so the order only changes when the underlying data changes.
Which pizza place in Oak Park, MI has the highest Google rating?
Mother Handsome has the highest rating among these entries: 4.7 stars from 354 reviews. Pie Sci Pizza follows at 4.5 stars from 264 reviews, and Pizza Square has 4.4 stars from 217 reviews.
Where can I get late-night pizza in Oak Park, MI?
Papa’s Pizza & BBQ at 15400 W Nine Mile Rd, Domino’s at 13735 W Nine Mile Rd, and Happy’s Pizza at 13700 W Nine Mile Rd close at 1 a.m. on Fridays and Saturdays and midnight the rest of the week. Little Caesars at 8801 W Nine Mile Rd closes at midnight on Fridays and Saturdays and 11 p.m. on other days.
Which pizza places in Oak Park, MI offer vegan or gluten-free options?
Pie Sci Pizza at 8150 W Nine Mile Rd offers both vegan and gluten-free options. Mother Handsome and Pizza Square also list vegan and vegetarian offerings.
Where can I sit down for pizza in Oak Park, MI?
Mother Handsome offers dine-in service, table service, outdoor seating, and an onsite bar, and accepts reservations. Happy’s Pizza and Pizza Square also offer dine-in seating, but neither offers table service or accepts reservations.
How do the two Little Caesars locations in Oak Park, MI compare?
The location at 8801 W Nine Mile Rd opens at 10:30 a.m. daily, offers a drive-through, and closes at 11 p.m. Sunday through Thursday and midnight Friday and Saturday. The location at 24756 Coolidge Hwy runs from 11 a.m. to 10 p.m. daily. Both offer delivery and takeout rather than dine-in service. Review excerpts for both locations report long waits.
1
